"From what we have already said on the subject of this work, its general character may easily be inferred. It appears to us an useful and comprehensive collection of English poetry, and the Editor has uniformly evinced diligence and judgment in collecting and arranging his materials."—Monthly Review, Sept. 1798.

"The Biographical and Critical Prefaces, as they are an original work, require a more distinct and particular examination. To the execution of this plan, Dr. Anderson seems to have brought powers well adapted to its completion. He appears to possess an accurate acquaintance with our poetry. His criticisms evince a mind capable of estimating the genuine beauties of the Muse, and candour willing to give praise in return for the pleasure he has received.

"We consider the present work as a valuable acquisition to English literature. As a collection of British Poetry and Biography, it confers honour upon the Editor for genius, taste, and in formation, tending to promote and perpetuate the most imperishable monument of Britain's glory."—British Critic, Feb. 1796.