565
POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY

Fig. 4. Attempted Restoration of the Parthenopian Volcano as it appeared in Strabo's Time. After Pellegrino, 1651. (The site of Veseri is conjectural.)
The problem of the geologist is to determine the past condition of things from what he is able to find out from the present. Nevertheless, the tendency of popular opinion has been to subordinate geologic to documentary evidence, and the majority of standard works continue to uphold the view that Vesuvius proper was non-existent at the time Herculaneum and Pompeii were overwhelmed. As positive a statement of this view as any is the following, from Professor Phillips' excellent work on 'Vesuvius':
Equally confident is the tone assumed by Professor Judd, in his volume on 'Volcanoes' in the International Science Series: